Douglas A. Anderson’s A Shiver in the Archives has a good new article on The H.P. Lovecraft Collection of Jack Grill and (later) Irving Binkin.

According to Wetzel, Grill “collected HPL photos, letters written to and by HPL; he interviewed HPL acquaintances, visited many of the Middle Atlantic and New England towns to which HPL had made antiquarian tours, and accumulated many other odds and ends of Lovecraftiana.” An odd, shy man, Grill wished he was “a writing fellow,” but his only writings were letters — in an execrable hand-writing, without paragraphs and mostly without dates.

The collections was purchased by Binkin in New York…

Having seen the photographs [of Lovecraft in the collection], Binkin realized that Lovecraft had been a regular customer at his bookstore, just off Red Hook in Brooklyn, over forty years earlier.

Wetzel, in his memoir of Grill, quotes a letter from Grill (circa June 1957) stating he’d acquired unpublished stories by Hazel Heald, “The Basement Room” (5 pages) and “Lair of the Fungus Death” (25 pages), from Heald herself.

Given the clunky titles, I’d expect that the Heald stories were not ones revised by Lovecraft.

But the Binkin bookshop is an interesting new point of street-level data about Lovecraft’s time in New York City in the 1920s. One wonders if an address can be pinned on it and a photo found?

54 Willoughby Street (1961 —)

A Directory of the early 1980s lists “Binkin’s Book Center, 54 Willoughby Street, Brooklyn”. The address is off Fulton St. and certainly fits the description of “just off Red Hook in Brooklyn”. A Bargain Hunter Guide of 1990 noted that “Binkin’s is the oldest bookstore [in the city]”. There is however a problem in assuming that this was always his location. For the Antiquarian Bookman for 1961 has…

“IRVING BINKIN. NEW LOCATION — ENTIRE BUILDING – FIVE FLOORS OF BOOKS. BINKIN’S. BOOK. CENTER. 54 Willoughby St., Brooklyn”

Thus it appears he only moved there circa 1961. Where Wally Dobelis remembered him in the 1960s…

Irving Binkin, in the back of Brooklyn Heights and the courthouse, on Willoughby Street, had a four-story building, the ground floor of which was devoted to making a living. Irving’s heart was really in ballroom dancing, of which he was a champion. He liked to go to Hispanic dances, and had a small Spanish book stock for his dance partners. Upstairs, he held residues of good Brooklyn estates, unpriced and unevaluated, books, paintings and ephemera. After much negotiating, Irving had decided that we were trustworthy and would not stuff our pockets, and could be permitted to make selections and bring them down for pricing. Irving was not knowledgeable, but prided himself on being able to divine, from our body language, things about the value of our selections. It did work out, since he asked for our scholarship, and we were not out to steal high value items for pennies. It was fun. I found some Elihu Vedder lithographs…

Hunting this erroneous location, however, did lead me to two evocative photos from the fringes of Red Hook…

This eBay picture is from 1927, looking east along Willoughby with No. 54 ahead in the near middle-distance on the right of the street…

The sign on the far right states “Baked Beans”, a Lovecraft staple. He refers in his letters to “Red Hook’s modestly priced bean-bureaus”. A 1928 photo of Jay and Willoughby shows the same distinctive building on the corner, and the cafe and its distinctive corner-sign on the other corner…

We know that Lovecraft frequented a cafe on this street…

John’s — the Italian joint around the corner in Willoughby St.

We can also see that this picture is looking down Jay St toward the Star Theatre as seen on the map, and the theatre is advertising Burlesque girlie shows with its signage. This picture and its identification as ‘Jay’ clearly confirms the location of the other 1927 photo and that it just-about shows No. 54 in the middle distance on the right.

---

162 Pierrepont Street (later 1950s-1961)

However, we must step back further in time to Binkin’s earlier book store. This was on Pierrepont Street, the address given by Book Dealers in North America, 1956. Photographs of this store dated 1958 are on the Brooklyn Historical Society website. Obviously he was getting ready for his move to Willoughby Street, appearing to be a ’25-cents a book’ guy and thus generating a big low-cost stock that he could sell for higher prices at Willoughby Street in a few years’ time…

But again it’s hazardous to assume that this was the same as the store he had since the early 1930s.

We do however know that Lovecraft’s best friend Samuel Loveman knew Binkin. Also in the book trade, Loveman evidently once had a copy of Clark Ashton Smith’s poems Ebony and Crystal (1922). This is currently for sale by L.W. Currey and “a presentation inscription by Samuel Loveman, the book’s dedicatee, to bookseller Irving Binkin is present on the title page.” However, what date this book might have been gifted has to be uncertain. Perhaps the 1930s, when Binkin first set up in the book trade? Or perhaps a friendly gift in the 1970s, on rescuing the Grill collection? We shall probably never know.

---

252 Fulton Street.

A kind credit in Richard Morris’s scholarly book Reading Finnegans Wake (1959), and a book trade directory entry, shows that he was at 252 Fulton Street before Pierrepont Street…

The Bookshop of Isei Binkin
252 Fulton Street.

Fulton Street is of course a name well known to those who have read up on Lovecraft in New York in the 1920s, and especially his epic pursuit of a new suit at a cheap price. The dedication usefully give us Binkin’s Jewish name, which may help someone to track down where exactly he was selling books in Brooklyn, and thus where he might have been patronised by Lovecraft.

One ad Binkin placed stated that his business was “Established 1932”. So even if the 252 Fulton Street address in Brooklyn is his first such store, that would mean that Lovecraft would not have been a frequent customer there in the 1920s when he was living in New York.

And even here we can’t quite even be sure that this was where Binkin was trading from 1932 to perhaps the mid 1950s when Morris knew him. Until circa 1913 the address appears to have been a cheap and rather notorious flop-house hotel for sailors. Then after the War it appears to have been renovated into apartments and boutique shops. For instance, the American Florist for 1922 has… “S. Mastir, 256 Fulton Street, Brooklyn. We found in addition to his fine stock of cut flowers, an excellent collection of palms and other foliage plants.”

Thus a book store there from 1932 onward seems not unlikely. We know from Frank Belknap Long that the antiquarian shops along Fulton Street were not unknown to Lovecraft… “[Roman coins and] baked-clay Roman lamps, and he [Lovecraft] once helped me pick out magnificent examples of both ‘coinage and lampage’ at an old-coin shop on Fulton Street.” (Dreamer on the Nightside) Although it might be that this was the other Fulton St., to be found across the Brooklyn Bridge.

---

Of course, it is just possible that Binkin was ’embroidering history’ after he purchased the Grill collection, and was only claiming that he remembered having Lovecraft browsing in his shop back in the 1920s or 30s. Possibly he mis-remembered circa 1970 and another customer conveniently ‘morphed into Lovecraft’ in his memory, when hazily recalled over the distance of more than 40 years. But then there is also the possibility that Belkin had started in the book trade in the mid 1920s as a youthful assistant in someone else’s book store, and it was from that period that he genuinely remembered Lovecraft’s distinctive face.