• About
  • Directory
  • Free stuff
  • Lovecraft for beginners
  • My Books
  • Open Lovecraft
  • Reviews
  • Travel Posters
  • SALTES

Tentaclii

~ News and scholarship on H.P. Lovecraft (1890–1937)

Tentaclii

Category Archives: Doyle

Audiobook: The Last Galley

24 Wednesday Aug 2022

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Podcasts etc.

≈ Leave a comment

New on Librivox, Conan Doyle’s book The Last Galley, Impressions and Tales (1911). This is from before Doyle’s marked turn to spiritualism.

Doyle writes in his introduction…

The first half is made up of a series of pictures of the past … there is a region between actual story and actual history which has never been adequately exploited. I could imagine, for example, a work dealing with some great historical epoch, and finding its interest not in the happenings to particular individuals, their adventures and their loves, but in the fascination of the actual facts of history themselves. These facts might be coloured with the glamour which the writer of fiction can give…

The Academy remarked, in a review of the book on publication in 1911, that the evocations of the first section would make an excellent accompaniment to a tiresome journey…

The classical section, consisting of some 124 pages, is extremely well done and transports us into the atmosphere of the period in which the tales are told.

In the Librivox reading this historical section runs for three and a half hours.

In the eight stories that then make up the second half of the book, we end with “The Terror of Blue John Gap”. This is a upland monster-horror set in and beneath the Peak District of England, where the Midlands rises to meet the rocky North. The specific location it was based on would likely be Treak Cliff Cavern near Castleton, a Peak mine since Ancient Roman times and a source for ‘Blue John’ rock which the story title alludes to. The cave played a key role in the discovery of the principle of evolution by Erasmus Darwin.

“Having gathered these facts, Watson, I smoked several pipes over them…”

14 Sunday Aug 2022

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Historical context

≈ 1 Comment

My Patreon patron John Miller asks…

Did HPL read Sherlock Holmes, and what did he think of this character and these stories?

The young Lovecraft certainly read the Holmes tales. As he recalled for Alfred Galpin, in a letter of 27th May 1918…

As to ‘Sherlock Holmes’ — I used to be infatuated with him! I read every Sherlock Holmes story published, and even organised a detective agency when I was thirteen, arrogating to myself the proud pseudonym of S.H. This P.D.A. [Providence Detective Agency] — whose members ranged between nine & fourteen in years, was a most wonderful thing — how many murders & robberies we unravelled! Our headquarters were in a deserted house just out of the thickly settled area…

That would be around 1902/3, the period in which a revolver was constantly carried in the pocket (sans ammunition) and a 99-cent spy-glass was newly on hand. Handcuffs, magnifying glasses, false beards and piercing whistles were also features of the P.D.A. We might suppose that the boys modelled themselves on the Baker Street irregulars, a group of boys found in the Holmes tales. But there may well have been other similar inspirations. He was also at this time reading Railroad man’s Magazine and the early Munsey proto-pulps. Lovecraft himself mentions…

Nick Carter and Old Sleuth, dear to the small boys of other generations, and studied almost invariably without knowledge or consent of the reader’s parents!

A list that Lovecraft made for Moe, recalling the multifarious concerns of the year 1900, includes… “Is Doyle going to write any more Sherlock Holmes books?”. Which suggests Lovecraft was also avid for Holmes in that year too.

The tales also spurred Lovecraft to a sustained period of writing, perhaps his first, as he told Kleiner on 2nd February 1916…

I used to write detective stories very often, the works of A. Conan Doyle being my model so far as plot was concerned.

As I’ve pointed out, the Holmes tales have plenty of gothic elements in them. They are not pure paeans to rationalism and scientific deduction.

In 1918 Lovecraft assumed he had read all of the Sherlock Holmes tales, but a footnote in the new edition of the Galpin letters itemises what he had read by 1927: three collections (Adventures, Memoirs, Return), three novels (Scarlet, Four, Hound) and two unnamed “mediocre” stories appearing circa 1908. I assume these were the 1908 tales “The Adventure of Wisteria Lodge” and “The Adventure of the Bruce-Partington Plans”. This shows that Lovecraft would have been up-to-date to summer 1908, but after that lost touch with the figure.

Which was rather a pity, as he missed the rest of the tales included in the book collections His Last Bow (1917) and all of the tales in The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (1927). Therefore it would be a mistake for future scholars to assume that the young Lovecraft had read “The Adventure of the Devil’s Foot”; “The Valley of Fear”; “The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire” or any other of the Case-Book tales.

What he did read may have had some later influence on Lovecraft’s ‘decadent’ phase. In the glimpses we have of this we sometimes sense Lovecraft as a figure not unlike Holmes in his limp ‘down-time’ periods behind the blinds at Baker Street. One might also see touches of this incorporated in “The Hound”, with both languid drug-taking and distant echoes of “The Hound of the Baskervilles” being woven into Lovecraft’s hilarious self-parody.

The boyhood Providence detective band appears to have faded away by 1905, and Lovecraft’s early interest in local ‘crime and grime’ did not continue. For instance he later remarked that as an adult he never read the “police reports” section in newspapers. Though one can see that he kept a ‘watching brief’ open on political crime, as evidenced by tales such as “The Street” (1919). He would also revisit local thuggery in his “The Terrible Old Man” (1920). Later in his life he sometimes took notice of ‘small crimes’. Crimes which may have been ‘petty’ in the eyes of the police, but which meant a lot to those involved. Such as the case of the missing stamp (recently detailed in an episode of the Voluminous podcast), a ‘missing cow’ hunt at Wilbraham, or of curiously missing cats on College Hill. In the latter case Lovecraft strongly suspected a local cat-poisoner, but it seems he did not do as far as to don a deerstalker and investigate Sherlock-style.

He saw, but was very disappointed by, the Sherlock Holmes movie of 1922. This movie did not, it seems, spark a Holmes revival among American boys. Lovecraft’s friend and fellow-writer Whitehead, a close observer of American boy-culture in evening clubs and summer-camps, remarked in a 1922 essay on the…

fact that there is just now growing up a generation of readers for whom the Doyle of ‘Sherlock Holmes’ is an obsolescent figure.

There is some indication that the adult Lovecraft read Doyle’s non-Holmes tales at the end of January 1925. In the 1925 Diary we hear…

home & read Meynell & Doyle

The listing of his library, made at his death, included Doyle’s collections Tales of Long Ago, and Tales of Twilight & the Unseen. (Doyle’s output in the weird line is surveyed in Wormwood #31, “The Dark and Decadent Dreams of Doctor Doyle”).

In September 1925 he told his aunt he intended to see the new movie of Doyle’s “The Lost World”, because it had become a ‘cheap-ticket show’ at the Strand. He notes the original novel had “charmed” him “some fifteen or more years ago”, which would put the reading at circa 1907-10.

We definitely know he borrowed Doyle volumes from the weird collector and friend Paul Cook, in summer 1929…

I am now about to go over the weird short stories of A. Conan Doyle — as many as I could round up in W. Paul Cook’s private library. Some of them I know, some of them I’ve read & forgotten, & some of them I seem never to have seen at all. It is quite possible that my opinion of Doyle as a weird writer will measurably increase within the next week or so!” [Later] “in the Doyle collection Cook lent me I recognised many of the old familiar tales, though there were a few I had not seen before. Doyle doesn’t affect me as powerfully as he did 25 or 30 years ago. In those days I got a real shudder out of things like “J. Habakuk Jephson”, “John Barrington Cowles”, “The Ring of Thoth”, & so on, but now I seem to sense the mechanics & the essential naivete. Doyle lacks some vague quality of mystical potency which Blackwood & Machen & De la Mare possess. But he is a good author for young readers, & I can see why he impressed me so strongly in the golden age of the [18]90’s & early 1900’s.

The latter point dates Lovecraft’s Doyle reading before 1900, into the later 1890s. The 1929 reading was undertaken for his survey of supernatural literature. I get the sense that the later Holmes stories (“Devil’s Foot”; “Valley of Fear” etc) were not included and thus remained unread. The Doyle volumes concerned were, surprisingly, then unavailable in the Providence Public Library. Which may perhaps be another indication of Doyle’s fading-away as a presence in American culture.

Lovecraft knew of Doyle’s well-publicised credulous spiritualist dalliances with everything from ectoplasm-exuding seance fraudsters to bottom-o’-the-garden fairy photography. Lovecraft knew from Houdini exactly how such fraud thrived, ghoulishly preying on the recently bereaved and mourning. He derided…

the cunningly doctored reports of “occult” phenomena popularised by men like [Sir Oliver] Lodge, [Conan] Doyle” (Lovecraft letter to Long, 1930).

To his aunt he lamented the loss of a fine writer to such malign forces…

What a writer Doyle was before he went to seed as a dupe of the spirit-mediums!


Further reading:

“The Problems with Solving: Implications for Sherlock Holmes and Lovecraft Narrators”, Lovecraft Studies #42-43 (Autumn 2001, double-issue).

“Elementary, My Dear Lovecraft”, Lovecraft Annual #6 (2012). (Detailed detection of possible Holmes influences on Lovecraft’s fiction).

The Robert H. Waugh Library of Lovecraftian Criticism, volume 3, reportedly has an essay on “the influence of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle on several Lovecraft tales”.

And see also the vast industry involving the creation of Holmes / Lovecraft mash-ups, something the young Lovecraft and his band of boys would no doubt have been rather delighted to learn about.

Conan Doyle and spiritualism

01 Friday May 2020

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Historical context

≈ 1 Comment

The Catholic Register explores the transition of Conan Doyle from Catholicism to the charlatanry of spiritualism…

“from 1918 onwards, books and bookshops, lectures and lecture tours were to follow, as Conan Doyle became the “Saint Paul of Spiritualism.” From then on, he was to expend more energy on this newfound belief in Spiritualism than on anything else. As a result, by the time of his death in 1930, his reputation lay in tatters.”

Such a pity he didn’t transfer such stuff into some wild and weird fiction, although to some he might seem to have touched on such things by 1910. For instance, when Sherlock Holmes steps down to Cornwall in 1910 (“The Adventure of the Devil’s Foot”), the reader also gets a lecture on possible Cornish Phoenician links that may extend (it is later barely hinted) not only to the Mediterranean but even into lost empires in Africa. This might sound to us like crackpot territory, yet for the Edwardians this was still a plausible though as-yet unproven hypothesis.

But spiritualism is definitely crackpot territory, then as now, and one can’t help but regret not being able to read the adventures and science-fantasies Doyle could have written after the war if he had not gone chasing after the fairies. I’m no Doyle expert beyond multiple readings of Holmes and knowing a bit about the West Midlands biographical connections and some related provincial stories, but after 1918 I see only the spiritualist apologia novel The Land of Mist (1926). As Lovecraft remarked several times in letters of the 1920s (I paraphrase from memory): ‘why don’t these deluded fellows pour their delusions into fiction, as they’d be far more fulfilled and their readers far more entertained.’

Of course, at that point in time even spiritualism and its ilk wasn’t quite so clear cut. The state of science was such that it wasn’t altogether implausible to suppose that ‘the fairies might be proved by science’ at any moment, even if they turned out to be early-morning dew-shapes forming in the air on electrical ‘kirlian’ coronal discharges from flowers, rather than diminutive nymphs with floaty dresses and dreamy smiles. One can equally see how it could have been just-about supposed that mediumship, ‘spiritual healing’, ESP, precognition, time-travel, aether-inhabiting ghosts, stone-circle construction via telekinetic levitation of rocks on ley-lines, and many other previously nebulous or uncertain ‘psychic’ phenomena were about to be somehow ‘proved’ or even ‘enabled’ by the new sciences. That was part of the attraction of such things I suppose, at that liminal moment of circa 1918-1928.

Much the same was true of mainstream archaeology and sound philology, then revealing vast new sweeps of time and major lost civilisations such as the Babylonians. One can see how easy it would have been in 1921 to imagine the steam-shovels digging down just another few feet to discover traces of a Conan-like Hyperborea, or an irrefutable fragment of some lost Atlantean super-civilisation, or just a Phoenician city-port under Roman London.

For further reading on the science angle here, an excellent survey book on the close intertwining of science and the occult is TechGnosis: Myth, Magic, and Mysticism in the Age of Information. I can’t immediately think of a similarly sweeping and high-quality history of the ‘lost archaeology and languages’ angle, on the interplay of real discovery and imaginative speculation, but I’d welcome hearing about it if one exists.

“The Horror Of The Heights”

18 Saturday Jan 2020

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Lovecraftian arts

≈ Leave a comment

A new 39 minute reading of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s “The Horror Of The Heights” (1913). The blurb is via Wikipedia and has plot spoilers, the opening being… “The story is told through a blood-stained notebook, dubbed the ‘Joyce-Armstrong Fragment’.” Other aspects are quite Lovecraftian, although the writing isn’t.

If the reader is not to your taste, HorrorBabble has it on YouTube in a good steady British English reading, and there are other readings on Librivox here (40 mins), here (42 mins) and here (36 mins).

Archive.org has the original appearance in The Strand magazine 1913, complete with superb colour plates. I won’t show these here as they’re visual spoilers.

H.P. Lovecraft read a good deal of Conan Doyle, as a lad in his ‘detective phase’. Joshi states that… “he read every Holmes story published up to that time (circa 1903)” and that these formed a key template for his early boyish fiction writing. Lovecraft wrote that… “I used to write detective stories very often, the works of A. Conan Doyle being my model so far as plot was concerned.”

He later recalled he had dipped a toe back into new Holmes stories in 1908, but found these… “an odd (& rather mediocre) pair or series of tales” and thereafter gave up on Holmes. If he also sampled the best of the non-Holmes horror, ghost and weird stories of Conan Doyle appears to be uncertain.

A story by Doyle titled “The Horror Of The Heights” would certainly have attracted Lovecraft’s attention. Yet he would probably have not seen it in The Strand, but rather in Doyle’s non-Holmes 1918 book collection Danger! and other stories. This would surely have arrived in the Providence Public Library in multiple copies and then been noticed by Lovecraft once the initial rush of borrowing of it had subsided — perhaps circa 1919. But more likely the nature of this particular story might have been called to his attention by someone in his circle, at some point in the mid 1920s, before he fully formulated shoggoths. While it appears we have no evidence of such a reading that I know of, we do know that in 1924 Lovecraft was discovering overlooked items such as Wells’s collection Thirty Strange Stories (1897, read January 1924), and Wells’s classic The Time Machine (1895, read November 1924). He was also doing much ‘catch up’ reading for his essay Supernatural Horror in Literature, with the aid of the New York libraries, the many used bookstores, and the private libraries of friends. Could he also have been sampling the best “strange stories” of Doyle, Kipling and others at this time?

Forefathers of Sword and Sorcery

04 Tuesday Jun 2019

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Historical context, REH

≈ Leave a comment

DMR has a developing series of short blog posts which introduce a set of “Forefathers of Sword and Sorcery”. The latest up for consideration, Arthur Conan Doyle. I must say I’d never even considered him as an influence on R.E. Howard, except in the vaguest way.

In addition to enjoying his Holmes stories, Doyle is also interesting to me for being another of the great names who have Birmingham and Staffordshire connections, alongside Wells, Tolkien, Borges and the Gawain-poet. For instance, I’ve reviewed Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands, which is the book you want if you’re interested in that topic or decide the take a literary touring holiday in Birmingham, Staffordshire and out into the neighbouring Welsh Marches.

Until reading DRM’s post I’d always thought of Doyle in terms of the always-re-readable Sherlock Holmes + some Edwardian horror stories. Even the fairy-world spiritualism of his dotage is of interest, because it tells one something about the pits of fraudulent charlatanry that opened up as religion faded, and how these could swallow up even highly intelligent people. This then reflects on the paths available to the early Wells, the young Tolkien, Kipling, Lovecraft and others, re: the cultural terrain they were navigating.

I must admit that I’ve never once encountered Doyle’s Professor Challenger adventure books, which DMR mentions, nor the various adventure and historical novels which the Doyle bibliography reveals. Professor Challenger is three novels, and two stories, apparently. Ho hum, yet another set of books to get around to… eventually! Ideally when a full-cast unabridged audiobook of such appears, and perhaps with Phil Dragash-like levels of avoidance of modern cynicism and hipster overtones in its vocal delivery.

Wormwood #31

23 Tuesday Oct 2018

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Kipling, New books, Scholarly works

≈ Leave a comment

Wormwood #31 has been published by Tartarus at £10.

Likely to be of most interest to readers of this blog is “The Dark and Decadent Dreams of Doctor Doyle” by Paul M. Chapman, on Conan Doyle’s non-Holmes tales in which… “His work often echoed Poe’s ‘love for the grotesque and the terrible’”.

Looking back over other issues of the last few years, I also see that #26 had a similar survey essay for Kipling, “The Strange and the Supernatural in the Short Stories of Rudyard Kipling” by Colin Insole.

“There are cases enough here, Watson,”

19 Thursday Jun 2014

Posted by asdjfdlkf in Doyle, Lovecraftian arts, Odd scratchings

≈ Leave a comment

Your Lovecraft-meets-Holmes pastiche idea gets the green light…

“Leslie S. Klinger has won his appeal against the Arthur Conan Doyle Estate, proving in the U.S. Court of Appeals that all [Holmes] material (including the characters of Sherlock Holmes and John Watson themselves) published prior to The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes [1927] is fair game for Sherlockians!”


 

Please become my patron at www.patreon.com/davehaden to help this blog survive and thrive.

Or donate via PayPal — any amount is welcome! Donations total at Summer 2022, since 2015: $340.

Archives

  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010

Categories

  • 3D (13)
  • Astronomy (57)
  • Censorship (13)
  • de Camp (6)
  • Doyle (7)
  • Films & trailers (88)
  • Fonts (8)
  • Guest posts (2)
  • Historical context (1,068)
  • Housekeeping (83)
  • Kipling (10)
  • Kittee Tuesday (74)
  • Lovecraft as character (38)
  • Lovecraftian arts (1,382)
  • Lovecraftian places (19)
  • Maps (58)
  • NecronomiCon 2013 (40)
  • NecronomiCon 2015 (22)
  • New books (864)
  • New discoveries (158)
  • Night in Providence (17)
  • Odd scratchings (851)
  • Picture postals (208)
  • Podcasts etc. (375)
  • REH (148)
  • Scholarly works (1,234)
  • Summer School (31)
  • Uncategorized (2)
  • Unnamable (85)

Get this blog in your newsreader:
 
RSS Feed — Posts
RSS Feed — Comments

H.P. Lovecraft's Poster Collection - 17 retro travel posters for $18. Print ready, and available to buy — the proceeds help to support the work of Tentaclii.

Proudly powered by WordPress Theme: Chateau by Ignacio Ricci.