Bobby Derie surveys “Farnsworth Wright’s Favorite Weird Tales”. Lovecraft’s own list is included is the essay, for comparison. The master had trawled his personal file of Weird Tales back-issues, most likely over Christmas 1929/30, and sent the ‘top six’ to Wright in Jan? 1930…
“Beyond the Door” — Paul Suter.
“The Floor Above” — M. Humphreys.
“The Night Wire” — H. F. Arnold.
“The Canal” — Everil Worrell.
“Bells of Oceana” — Arthur J. Burks.
He also remarks “I’d include [Frank Belknap Long’s] “Black Druid” if it were published.”