Discoverability of Scholarly Content

New White Paper from commercial publisher SAGE: Discoverability of Scholarly Content: Accomplishments, Aspirations and Opportunities, written after the moment…

“in 2013, [when commercial paywall] academic content providers around the world were forced to consider alternate methods of open-web discoverability when Google’s primary web search ceased its special treatment of access-controlled scholarly materials”

The consusus here and elsewhere seems to be ‘just add metadata’ to open content, and it will slot right into existing closed discovery systems. Good luck with that one, and don’t forget to shut the stable door.

Interesting comment spotted in the paper, in relation to the oft-heard complaint that Google uses closed proprietary search algorithms…

“The research also noted the variability among [academic library Web-scale] discovery services’ proprietary search algorithms, which — lacking transparency — disallows local customization, which libraries and end users expect.”

What it doesn’t mention is the quality of the ranking done by the proprietary search algorithms in services such as Summon. To see what I mean, try the dozy search | what is history carr | in Summon, then try it again in JURN.

Major EU legal ruling on hyperlinks

Web hyperlinking to freely available online content does not amount to publishing an illegal communication, says a major new ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union. Linking to open content cannot communicate it to a new public audience, since the content is already public.

However, the ruling says nothing of the taxing of Web links to open content, a loopy idea proposed by French socialists among others.

Search-engines for spooks

The US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) want to build Google-style custom search engines for spooks, or as they phrase it… “domain-specific indexing of web content [with] domain-specific search capabilities”. Might be nice if they could also invite worthy non-profits like JURN to park up on their uber-servers for free, with maybe 10,000 domain URLs to play with — compared to the 5,000 URL limit Google places on its CSEs.