A Chartist leader escapes from the Potteries, 1842

A Chartist leader escapes from the Potteries, 1842. From The Life of Thomas Cooper:

At dusk, I closed the [Chartist] meeting; but I saw the people did not disperse; and two pistols were fired off in the crowd. No policeman had I seen the whole day! And what had become of the soldiers I could not learn. I went back to my inn; but I began to apprehend that mischief had begun which it would not be easy to quell. […] two Chartist friends went out to hire a gig [horse carriage] to enable me to get to the Whitmore station, that I might get to Manchester: there was no railway through the Potteries, at that time. But they tried in several places, and all in vain. No one would lend a gig, for it was reported that soldiers and policemen and special constables had formed a kind of cordon round the Potteries, and were stopping up every outlet.

Midnight came, and then it was proposed that I should walk to Macclesfield, and take the coach there at seven the next morning, for Manchester. Two young men, Green and Moore, kindly agreed to accompany me; and I promised them half-a-crown each.

[He disguises himself] Miss Hall, the daughter of Mr. Hall the land-lord of the George and Dragon, lent me a hat and great-coat I put them on, and putting my travelling cap into my bag, gave the bag to one of the young men, and my cloak to the other; and, accompanied by Bevington and other friends, we started. They took me through dark streets to Upper Hanley; and then Bevington and the rest bade us farewell, and the two young men and I went on.

My friends had purposely conducted me through dark streets, and led me out of Hanley in such a way that I saw neither spark, smoke, or flame. [of the riot, and] during that night scenes were being enacted in Hanley, the possibility of which had never entered my mind, when I so earnestly urged those excited thousands to work no more till the People’s Charter became the law of the land. Now thirty years have gone over my head, I see how rash and uncalculating my conduct was. But, as I have already said, the demagogue is ever the instrument rather than the leader of the mob.

[Instruction was given to] the two young men, Green and Moore, who accompanied me, not to go through Burslem, because the special constables were reported to be in the streets, keeping watch during the night; but to go through the village of Chell, and avoid Burslem altogether.

I think we must have proceeded about a mile in our night journey when we came to a point where there were two roads; and Moore took the road to the right while Green took that to the left.

[… they argue tediously for some minutes …]

” I tell thee that I’m right,” said the one.

” I tell thee thou art wrong,” said the other.

And so the altercation went on, and they grew so angry with each other that I thought they would fight about it.

” This is an awkward fix for me,” said I, at length. “You both say you have been scores of times to Chell, and yet you cannot agree about the way. You know we have no time to lose. I cannot stand here listening to your quarrel. I must be moving some way. You cannot decide for me. So I shall decide for myself. I go this way,” — and off I dashed along the road to the left, Moore still protesting it led to Burslem, and Green contending as stoutly that it led to Chell.

They both followed me, however, and both soon recognised the entrance of the town of Burslem, and wished to go back.

” Nay,” said I, “we will not go back. You seem to know the other way so imperfectly, that, if we attempt to find it, we shall very likely get lost altogether. I suppose this is the highroad to Macclesfield, and perhaps it is only a tale about the specials [volunteer night-guards at Burslem].’

In the course of a few minutes we proved that it was no tale. We entered the market-place of Burslem, and there, in full array, with the lamp-lights shining upon them, were the Special Constables! The two young men were struck with alarm; and, without speaking a word, began to stride on, at a great pace. I called to them, in a strong whisper, not to walk fast — for I knew that would draw observation upon us. But neither of them heeded. Two persons, who seemed to be officers over the specials, now came to us. Their names, I afterwards learned, were Wood and Alcock, and they were leading manufacturers in Burslem.

” Where are you going to, sir? ” said Mr. Wood to me. “Why are you travelling at this time of the night, or morning rather. And why are those two men gone on so fast?”

“I am on the way to Macclesfield, to take the early coach for Manchester,” said I; “and those two young men have agreed to walk with me.”

” And where have you come from?” Asked Mr. Wood; and I answered, “From Hanley.”

“But why could you not remain there till the morning ?”

“I wanted to get away because there are fires and disorder in the town — at least, I was told so, for I have seen nothing of it.”

Meanwhile, Mr. Alcock had stopped the two young men.

“Who is this man?” He demanded; “and how happen you to be with him, and where is he going to?

“We don’t know who he is,” answered the young men, being unwilling to bring me into danger” he has given us half-a-crown a piece, to go with him to Macclesfield. He’s going to take the coach there for Manchester, to-morrow morning.”

” Come, come,” said Mr. Alcock, “you must tell us who he is. I am sure you know.”

The young men doggedly protested that they did not know.

“I think,” said Mr. Wood, “the gentleman had better come with us into the Legs of Man” (the principal inn, which has the arms of the Isle of Man for its sign), “and let us have some talk with him.”

So we went into the inn, and we were soon joined by a tart-looking consequential man.

“What are you, sir?” Asked this ill-tempered-looking person.

“A commercial traveller,” said I, resolving not to tell a lie, but feeling that I was not bound to tell the whole truth. And then the same person put other silly questions to me, until he alighted on the right one, ” What is your name ?”

I had no sooner told it, than I saw Mr. Alcock write something on a bit of paper, and hand it to Mr. Wood. As it passed the candle I saw what he had written, — “He is a Chartist lecturer.”

“Yes, gentlemen,” I said, instantly, “I am a Chartist lecturer; and now I will answer any question you may put to me.”

“That is very candid on your part. Mr. Cooper,” said Mr. Alcock.

” But why did you tell a lie, and say you were a commercial traveller?” – asked the tart-looking man.

“I have not told a lie,” said I; “for I am a commercial traveller, and I have been collecting accounts and taking orders for stationery that I sell, and a periodical that I publish, in Leicester.”

“Well, sir,” said Mr. Wood, “now we know who you are, we must take you before a magistrate. We shall have to rouse him from bed; but it must be done.”

Mr. Parker was a Hanley magistrate, but had taken alarm when the mob began to surround his house, before they set it on fire, and had escaped to Burslem. He had not been more than an hour in bed, when they roused him with the not very agreeable information that he must immediately examine a suspicious-seeming Chartist, who had been stopped in the street. I was led into his bedroom, as he sat in bed, with his night-cap on. He looked so terrified at the sight of me — and bade me stand farther off, and nearer the door! In spite of my dangerous circumstances I was near bursting into laughter. He put the most stupid questions to me; and at his request I turned out the contents of my carpet-bag, which I had taken from the young men, with the thought that I might be separated from them. But he could make nothing of the contents – either of my night-cap and stockings, or the letters and papers it held.

Mr. Wood at last said, “Well, Mr. Parker, you seem to make nothing out in your examination of Mr. Cooper. You have no witnesses, and no charges against him. He has told us frankly that he has been speaking in Hanley; but we have no proof that he has broken the peace. I think you had better discharge him, and let him go on his journey.”

Mr. Parker thought the same, and discharged me. His house was being burnt at Hanley while I was in his bedroom at Burslem. I was afterwards charged with sharing the vile act. But I could have put Mr. Parker himself into the witness-box to prove that I was three miles from the scene of riot, if the witnesses against me had not proved it themselves. The young men, by the wondrous Providence which watched over me, were prevented going by way of Chell. If we had not gone to Burslem, false witnesses might have procured me transportation for life [to Australia as a convict].

Were these young men true to me? Had they deserted me, and gone back to Hanley ? No: they were true to me, and were waiting in the street; and now cheerily took the bag and cloak, and we sped on again, faster. We had been detained so long, however, that by the time we reached the “Red Bull,” a well-known inn on the highroad between Burslem and the more northern towns of Macclesfield, Leek, and Congleton, one of the young men, observed by his watch that it was now too late for us to be able to reach Macclesfield in time for the early coach. The other young man agreed; and they both advised that we should strike down the road, at the next turning off to the left, and get to Crewe — where I could take the railway for Manchester. We did so; and had time for breakfast at Crewe, before the Manchester train came up, when the young men returned [to the Potteries].

A second special Providence was thus displayed in my behalf. If we had proceeded in the direction of Macclesfield, in the course of some quarter of an hour we should have met a crowd of working men, armed with sticks, coming from Leek and Congleton to join the riot in the Potteries. That I should have gone back with them, I feel certain; and then I might have been shot in the street, as the leader of the outbreak.

“And as far off as Birmingham?” – a review of the book Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands

Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands is a small 8” x 6” book of 125 pages, and is an excellent read. Clearly written and well researched by Paul Lester, it is logically arranged and illustrated with period illustrations, crisp contemporary photographs of sites, plus a few basic maps. Apparently it originated as a 20-page 1980s fanzine in Birmingham, but here it becomes a proper local history book. The typesetting is professional, and chapter endnotes are set in a font size that is readable without a magnifying glass. There is no final bibliography, but the bibliographic endnotes for chapters supply all the references any scholar of Holmes might require. Published in 1992, the book’s stiff covers and glue-binding have been quite adequate for 25 years, but in my copy the glue is obviously failing, with several pages almost coming loose in 2017. If a purchase of this book is being made for archival purposes, then a rebinding may be needed.

This book is best suited to those who know both Holmes and the proper1 West Midlands — the former Mercia which stretches from Herefordshire and Worcestershire and Evesham in the south, up through Birmingham and Lichfield, to the Potteries and the Peak District moorlands in the north. Almost nothing is said in the book of the East Midlands, and a casual purchaser from Nottinghamshire or Leicestershire will be sorely disappointed. I, however, was delighted by the book. Because at a great many points I was able to make a connection with places where I had grown up, where I had lived or where I now live, or places I had visited. This is due to my particular family-history, and also my childhood and workplace connections. I was especially interested in Aston and Corporation St. in Birmingham, and pleased to find that these places are extensively discussed in the book. I was even instructed on the correct pronunciation (albeit Shropshire rather than Staffordshire) of the Norman name of the place where I now live.

The book opens in the Welsh Marches, rural Shropshire, where Conan Doyle was a medical student working as an unpaid intern to a truculent local doctor. Even at that slight geographical remove from the Welsh heartlands, it appears that Conan Doyle formed there a clear prejudice regarding the Welsh tendency to nurture the sour and resentful aspects of their nature. The book then deals in a substantial manner with Doyle’s happier internship, working for a doctor in Aston, a jolly and hard-working man who welcomed the intelligent young lad into his bustling family. Aston, I should explain for the unfamiliar reader, is very near the centre of the city of Birmingham. I was delighted to learn that Doyle “saw a very deal of the very low life” in Aston between mid 1879 and February 1880, as a visiting doctor, because that meant he might have been rubbing shoulders with my ancestors in Aston. Perhaps even treating one of them, since a key female relative was plucked from poverty in Weeman Row, a slum since cleared and now roughly underneath the current Children’s Hospital at the east end of Corporation St.

Lester usefully points out possible connections of places and place names with Holmes stories, but he doesn’t labour his points. He also usefully summarises and evaluates the speculations of previous Holmes scholars, but again briefly and with a very light touch. Thus the reader learns that there was a violin seller in Sherlock Street in Birmingham city centre at the time Doyle was working there (mid 1897-February 1880, and again in early 1882), but this is not claimed as a sure-fire inspiration for Sherlock Holmes, merely suggested as one such possible example. Doyle’s keen interest in photography while in Birmingham is later mentioned in an aside, and I thought it a pity that more was not said of this. Perhaps it might have been explored in a few paragraphs added to the chapter on Doyle’s Midlands spiritualist connections and spirit photography. In that chapter I was however fascinated to read a full account of Doyle’s duping by spiritualist forgers at Crewe (a stone’s throw outside the Midlands, being a large railway town not far from the Potteries), and learned there once existed a ‘Society for the Study of Paranormal Pictures’, of which Doyle was the Hon. Sec. It seems incomprehensible today that the effective removal of the assured comforts of the Christian religion by science could have displaced the old religious sentiments in such gross directions. In Doyle’s case, into a belief in such obvious charlatanry as spiritualism, spirit photography and the idea that bottom-of-the-garden fairies could be photographed. Yet, Doyle credulously championed them all, and was often flanked by accomplished scientists such as the Potteries man Oliver Lodge.

As well as tracking Sherlock Holmes through the Midlands counties of Herefordshire, Warwickshire, and up into the Peak District, some of the local non-Holmes stories are also noted. Personally I would have been inclined to add an extra chapter just to explore these stories and their settings. These are stories such as “The Doings of Raffles Haw” (set “14 miles north of Birmingham” in the wedge of mid Staffordshire country between Lichfield and Tamworth); the fine horror story “The Terror of Blue John Gap” (the Peak District, ‘Blue John’ implying Castleton); and the weird story “The Japanned Box” (near Evesham, in the far south of the Midlands). Doyle’s real-life investigation of the Great Wyrley police conviction of George Edalji is given another re-telling, with careful summation and evaluation.

Shropshire and Herefordshire are places I only know from early and middle childhood, but so far as I can tell Lester’s book is sound on all the points of local geography for the various counties. Which is not the case for the Penguin Classics notes found in a key Holmes edition — in which cloistered academics misleadingly parrot local tourism puffery that Walsall is… “in the heart of what is known as the Black Country” — when it’s at the far end of it and the “heart” is around Tipton. Sherlock Holmes never stalked the industrial districts of the Black Country or the Potteries, and so far as I know (I’ve read all the stories three times now, the last read-through being about ten years ago) there is no substantial descriptive mention of such places. Though this very absence might suggest locations for the writers of newly-minted Holmes stories, the characters now being in the public domain. Thus the Black Country cannot claim a setting used for a Holmes story, but in Lester’s book I learned that the Industrial Museum there does now have the original ‘pillar box’ (red iron post-box, into which the public could post hand-written letters and postcards) that once stood in Baker St. in London. Other fascinating snippets I learned included the insight that the local makers of umbrellas, sewing machines and watches in Birmingham and Coventry all contributed some aspect of their skills to the invention of the first modern bicycles (Doyle, like Wells, was a keen cyclist, and I have an interest in the trade due to a long line of bicycle makers in my main family-tree). It takes a while to think that one through, but it’s correct and is a fascinating spotlight on how inventions arise in dense industrial districts in which many trades mix and mingle in a free market. Before reading this book I had also not known that Samuel Johnson of Lichfield — the famous dictionary maker — had started his literary career at Old Square, just off Corporation St. in Birmingham. Thus Corporation St. can claim to have been a formative influence on Johnson was well as on Tolkien.

This is a fascinating read for those interested in its locations. It is formed from a blend of well-tested Holmes scholarship and new primary sources, polished up with much pavement-pounding at the actual locations. Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands is well worth your £3-£5 when it pops up in used form on Amazon or eBay. Might we hope for an expanded and updated ebook version, at some point in the future? Perhaps surveying the non-Holmes Midlands stories, expanding on Doyle’s interest in photography at Aston, and surveying or listing the best of the Holmes fan fiction set in the West Midlands?


1. proper West Midlands — There is also a vile 1970s bureaucratic invention calling itself the West Midlands, but which only covers a Birmingham/Coventry portion of the real West Midlands. It seems to be merely a way of grabbing taxpayer funding without having to then share it with the surrounding towns and rural areas.

For the birds…

Here’s a free ‘bird’ book cover. Not great, and it all went a bit muddy in the end — so ‘Creative Commons Attribution’, and feel free to use for the cover of a poetry book, nature notes books etc. May look better in black and white.

Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands

I’ve today fished a bargain ex-library copy of Sherlock Holmes in the Midlands out of my postbox. An excellent small book on Conan Doyle and Holmes, of which I’ve so far read the introduction and first two chapters (the first being rural Shropshire, and then suburban Aston in Birmingham, following Conan Doyle’s early career as a medical assistant). Well researched, and well written. There are currently two more copies at under £3 on Amazon, inc. postage, if any reader of this blog wants to grab one before they’re sold. It appears to be more usually listed with a bit of a ‘scholarly rarity’ premium added, at above £20.

Update: my review.

Natural Navigator: a lichen mnemonic

I was watching a Tristan Gooley (Natural Navigator) video on YouTube, where he shows how to tell north from where certain rusty shades of tree lichens grow on tree trunks. Find a couple of large patches on a lichened tree and you can be sure where north is. It seemed to need a new mnemonic rhyme for children, so I made one…

  Round and round the trunk we goes,
  to find the way the wind a’ blows.
  Where large the rusty lichen grows,
  to that way point your northy nose.
  Now sniff the wind, and off we goes!

Once you know where north is, and can tell from that what the prevailing wind direction is, then all sorts of natural indicators become available from that. Such as cloud movements seen inside woods, which side of copses birds are sheltering on, where spiders have spun webs on bushes, and suchlike.

Insense

Insense: a word which survived in use in Staffordshire until at least the late 1820s. Seeming to mean: to inform or briefly instruct a group of people about information useful to them, thus helping them to make sense of a situation.

Source: The Gentleman’s Magazine Library: being a classified collection.

The Monthly Magazine of 1806 talks of…

insense, to instruct, or put in the head of any one: as for instance, the judge is said to insense the jury how to bring in their verdict”

The Atheneum of 1827 referred to it as Scottish and/or Scots-Irish…

“to unravel those mysteries which the people want taste and leisure to study for themselves, and to insense the multitude (I like that Hibernicism) on their dearest interests”

It is referred to as “a north country expression” in a memoir of 1869 (A Memoir of H. Hoare), so was at that time either dying out or had never existed in the south of England.

But, since Shakespeare used it, it may once have been present as far south as south Warwickshire.

Ceramics in board-game sets

A jasperware chess set, made in north Staffordshire and most likely by Wedgwood, perhaps 1800-1820s.

I suppose the fragility of early ceramic meant it wasn’t favoured for small board-game pieces. Too easily brushed off the table, to smash on the floor. But now the industry has the unbreakable Steelite-style of ceramics, one wonders about a revival of the use of ceramics in board-game sets?

Erasmus Darwin’s The Botanic Garden – a survey of the best podcasts and ebook version

As a sidelight on my new book on H.G. Wells in the Potteries, I’m currently reading Erasmus Darwin’s book-length poem The Botanic Garden: the Economy of Vegetation (1791) in its free Gutenberg version (clean in .ePub and Kindle .mobi, with the original footnotes, corrected long-s, and line numbers).

Here are some recommended introductory podcasts on local man Erasmus Darwin:

* “Erasmus Darwin: People, Language, & History Connections”, a nippy little fast-paced and friendly 15-minute introduction, from a popular podcaster.

* The 14 minute “The Poetry of Erasmus Darwin’s The Botanic Garden is also rather good. The best of a mostly rather dry series of such videos made by academics, apparently for the public.

The only broadcast documentary I can find is John Scotney’s “A Mind of Universal Sympathy”, though it’s not online. It was a long BBC Radio 3 partly-dramatised narrated documentary, broadcast in September 1973. Re-broadcast in 1974 and 1978, but probably now lost due to the BBC’s criminal policy of not preserving their archives in the 1980s and 90s. Such a pity that our regional archives never thought to record such key broadcasts on good reel-to-reel tape. An oral history interview with Desmond King-Hele, via the British Library, reveals more…

I also should mention the radio programme in 1973 called A Mind of Universal Sympathy. This was commissioned by John Scotney, one of the producers at the BBC, and it was really quite difficult to write, it was a dramatised documentary about Erasmus Darwin for Radio 3, it was forty five minutes [Radio Times suggests one hour] and it was a drama with Freddie Jones as Erasmus. It was very successful actually and financially one of my most successful things, because it was repeated several times on Radio 3 and they gave fees for those as well. I did another similar type of radio drama called The Lunatics covering the Lunar Society of Birmingham, again with Erasmus Darwin in a major role.”

Possibly these scripts might be rescued from archives somewhere, and re-made as a new semi-dramatised feature-documentary?

Illustration for The Botanic Garden, via The British Library.

I had been recommended to read The Botanic Garden years ago, I forget by whom, but was reminded of it again by Wells’s “The Cone”. In this macabre revenge short-story Wells has a wife talk of her iron-master husband and his… “dreadful theory of yours that machinery is beautiful […] It’s his great theory, his one discovery in art.” Thus for my footnotes to “The Cone” I investigated the extent of the ‘heavy industry and machinery is beautiful’ sentiment at the time, in art and literature, to see if there was an obvious source Wells might have been gesturing toward and expecting his readers to recognise. There was no obvious source, but few choices at that time. Darwin’s “The Economy of Vegetation” certainly celebrated the rising new industries in no uncertain terms, and had both a Etruria (Stoke) and a Staffordshire connection (Darwin was a Lichfield man). It was a best-seller and went through multiple editions, and thus was likely to be easily available in used and reprint copies in the Potteries by 1888. There were also pirated Irish and American editions due to its immense popularity.

In it there is a striking use of a vengeful husband and his revenge, as a metaphor for the earth’s making of iron in the earth, with fits with the theme of “The Cone”…

Indignant Vulcan eyed the parting Pair,
And watch’d with jealous step the guilty pair

[… he traps and fixes them in a mesh of metal, in their love-bed]

Hence dusky Iron sleeps in dark abodes,
And ferny foliage nestles in the nodes;
Till with wide lungs panting bellows blow,
And waked by fire the glittering torrents flow

With the book-length poem’s visions of a future Empire in the air with airships (“The flying-chariot through the fields of air. Fair crews triumphant, leaning from above”) and in submarines under the sea (“Britain’s sons shall guide | Huge sea-balloons beneath the tossing tide; The diving castles, roof’d with spheric glass, […] Buoy’d with pure air shall endless tracks pursue”) and a great many other items of interest to a budding purveyor of the future, one has to wonder if Wells may have read The Botanic Garden in 1888 or thereabouts. Certainly the botanical aspects of the didactic poem would also have interested him, complete with Erasmus’s own fascinating scientific footnotes. In 1888 Wells appears to have been somewhat light on the botany half of biology, and in need of ‘cramming’ on the topic if he was to teach the subject, perhaps another reason to ‘give it a go’.

However… I can find not a whit of hard evidence that Wells ever mentioned Erasmus, despite Erasmus’s pioneering championing of the cause of “enlisting the imagination under the banner of science”, and his practical linkage of Romanticism and speculative optimistic science (and thirty years before the birth of Jules Verne, to boot). Given Wells’s immense and prolific output, and his effective founding of futurology, this absence in itself is perhaps indicative of a key influence being cloaked from public scrutiny. But the lack of hard evidence has to mean that a Wells connection can only be very tentatively suggested.

Still, The Economy of Vegetation is proving to be an interesting read, especially when viewed as in part an early work of science-fiction. Interestingly, Lovecraft had a copy in his library, and he no doubt adored the blend of the 1700s poetic style with speculative science. The long-s style of Pope and Erasmus Darwin was by then deeply unfashionable, but it was one Lovecraft doggedly championed in public until well into the 1920s.

There’s more to be had locally, and very much in the Darwin style, in The vales of Wever, a loco-descriptive poem (1797) by John Gisborne. It ‘Erasmus-ifies’ Wootton, near Alton Castle, complete with the same style of explicatory footnotes. Rather usefully, the poem throws several lights on the otherwise-unknown natural history of the Gawain landscape.