The Botanic Institute, Burslem.

My novel The Spyders of Burslem features the last of the ‘cunning’ men, Jimmy Tunnicliffe, at the end of the 1860s. I’m pleased to discover that there was a real if rather more upmarket equivalent to Jimmy Tunnicliffe in Burslem and, by the looks of it, at more or less about the right time. Evidently there was a ‘Botanic Institute’ herbalist on The Sytch (which also appears in the novel), by the name of Ree Dar or Reedar.

If he could get out to country patients (see the bottom of the flyer) evidently he kept a horse and gig. Which would make sense, since he would also need to have a means of getting out of Stoke to gather herbs in their season. Though such people also had ‘gatherers’ I seem to recall.

More recent Tolkien work

Here are some more picks from the latest public and free Tolkien scholarship, following my last such. That was posted here back in November 2020.

* “The ‘Polish Inkling’: Professor Przemyslaw Mroczkowski as J.R.R. Tolkien’s Friend and Scholar”. May have something relevant, re: exactly when Tolkien first discovered his true ancestry. (Update, no insight re: ancestry, but it does illuminate Tolkien’s publication-history in Poland)

* “The Tale of the Old Forest: The Damaging Effects of Forestry in J.R.R. Tolkien’s Written Works”. “… Finally the essay reconstructs a linear history of the Old Forest through posthumously published materials such as Unfinished Tales of Numenor & Middle-earth to discover the causes of the Old Forest’s villainy”. (Update: lacks the hoped-for focus on deep-history ’causes’, unconvincing on these)

* “Tolkien and the Age of Forgery: Improving Antiquarian Practices in Arda”. “…Drawing on previously unpublished folios from Tolkien’s undergraduate notebooks…”. Nice, anything that gets access to unpublished items from that period is of interest to me. (Update: the “folios” turn out to be just lecture-notes from a first-year lecture he attended)

* “Alcuin and Cynewulf: the Art and Craft of Anglo-Saxon verse”. Text of the Sir Israel Gollancz Memorial Lecture for 2019. A section at the end… “considers the authorship and identity of Cynewulf”. Yes, since 1954 he’s no longer been considered by academics to have penned the actual earendel lines, but interesting all the same. (Update: the Appendix is substantial, and reconsiders the neglected ‘was he the Bishop of Lindisfarne’ suggestion, which was an early suggestion that was overtaken by later findings re: Mercia).

* “‘I Dwelt There Once’: Home, Belonging and Dislocation in J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings”. (Philosophy dissertation from Finland, and it looks fairly sound). (Update: An excellent piece of work, very illuminating of an important theme running through LOTR).

* “‘Her Enchanted Hair’: Rossetti, ‘Lady Lilith’, and the Victorian Fascination with Hair as Influences on Tolkien. “Gitter may claim that ‘the Victorian vision of magic hair did not survive long into the twentieth century’, but in Tolkien’s early- to mid-twentienth-century writing it is alive and well, and even embellished upon.”

The reading of my previous listing of interesting recent work yielded a variety of interesting items. Some observations: The Zeppelin essay was terrific and definitely informs the flying Nazgul and various forms of ‘far-seeing’ in LOTR. Tolkien was no palaeographer, despite his good ‘hand’ with a pen and his interest in ‘hands’ both in the speech-gestural and scribal meanings of the word. He was likely at work for the OED by Christmas 1918. The terrific new book The Transmission of Beowulf (2017) very strongly supports Tolkien’s early dating of Beowulf. The Rohirrim can be said to have early Mercian names, if one investigates the full names in the notes Tolkien made for the benefit of his translators. An Exeter Book photographic facsimile was produced in the early 1930s. A new earendel variant has been found in an early Gothic sermon. I also note that too many Tolkien items are still hidden away in tiny inaccessible journals such as Orcrist or obscure and expensive ‘academic library’ chapter collections, e.g. Larsen, Goering, and also the final reading of the earendel variant.

More regrettable changes at Facebook

More Facebook changes today. Shortly after the move to the new UI they had it perfect, apart from the annoying and utterly pointless “See more…” click-iness. They had saved themselves, after the Great Exodus.

But now they’re slowing starting to ruin it again, with more changes. They’re also soon to push more work on Group admins through regrettable back-end changes.

The latest change today is to huge ‘blaring’ images. These now overpower the text and links, and make it difficult to concentrate on these. The new ultra-wide central column now also makes it more difficult to read across the text. With this and the very unwelcome Group changes coming, I’m definitely considering taking all my Groups over to an amalgamated WordPress blog. Most likely with a newspaper-like template. By which I mean an old-school news newspaper, not one of the modern hives of clickbait and pop-ups. Though perhaps not quite this old-school.

It’s surprisingly difficult to use search to cut through the ocean of robo-made shovelware templates, but Gabfire’s old $60 WP Newspaper (aka Advanced Newspaper, or Advanced WordPress Newspaper) theme is still a classic and now in v3.6. Here blurred and inverted so you can see the basic structure and how it might look with a Dark Mode on it…

12 ‘lost things’ from Stoke

Twelve ‘lost things’ from Stoke:

1. Aurochs. Giant prehistoric wild cattle which survived to the Roman period, a skull of which was discovered in diggings at Etruria and is in the Potteries Museum.

2. The old Roman Road, through Wolstanton to where the current Stoke train station is. Though some of Rykeneld Street is likely still there, underground.

3. ‘The Lost Painting of Longton’. Robert Bateman’s large major oil painting “Saul and the Witch of Endor” was given to the city and was last heard of in Longton Town Hall in the early 1950s.

4. The vanished railway line from Stoke railway station to Newcastle-under-Lyme, which went through over 700 yards of tunnels to get there and went on the town of Market Drayton. Also the Potteries Loop Line around the city, though much of that now survives as off-road bicycle paths.

5. The old-style ‘very broad’ Potteries Dialect, now almost extinct.

6. The Etruria Woods, of which only remnants and re-growths now remain. One might also include the vast 55-mile long Lyme barrier-forest from the Norman era, which gave its name to Burslem.

7. The vast network of modern deep-mining tunnels. Now flooded, they run mostly from around Forest Park across the valley to Wolstanton.

8. Trentham Hall, offered to the Council as a miners’ hospital but unwanted and thus largely demolished. But the Gardens and Estate are now thriving.

9. Wedgwood’s secret glazes, for making pottery. When H.G. Wells was living in the Potteries, he roomed with a school-fellow who had the job of trying to reconstruct these secrets from the old dried-out glaze-pots in the cellars of Etruria Hall.

10. Folklore and old local tales, of which only fragments remain. Also related customs, such as the annual Hanley Venison Feast.

11. The North Staffordshire Field Club. Once one of the largest and well-patronised in the nation, with amateurs researching everything from local history and geology to local insects and birds. Like a burst seed-pod, it eventually withered away after giving life to a great many individual specialist groups.

12. The Trubshaw Cross at Longport. In the 1620s said to be the terminus of “a great passage out of the north parts unto diverse market towns”, serving the packhorse teams that bore the industries of the Peak (sheep-fleeces, metals etc) to Newcastle-under-Lyme and thence to the good roads that ran north and south. By the 1840s only the stone base of the cross, likely of “Saxon origin”, remained.

Thomas Pape (1872-1970)

Thomas Pape (1872-1970) was a key historian of North Staffordshire. He produced several local history books from 1928-40, and a number of articles can also be found. Sadly the books are not on Archive.org and the publisher — Manchester University Press — has not yet scanned the extensive series of which they are a part and put them online.

His key works are:

1. Medieval Newcastle-under-Lyme, Manchester University Press, 1928. No TOCs online, but his second book for the Press gives a summary of the first…

Ten years ago the Manchester University Press published the first volume, Medieval Newcastle-under-Lyme, a history of the Castle from its foundation in Stephen’s reign until its decay in the late fifteenth century, also a history of the borough from its formation in Henry II’s reign and a history of the Manor — all to the end of the reign of Henry VII. The two most important appendices were the extended Latin transcripts of the minute books of the borough of Newcastle-under-Lyme from 1369 to 1510.

1a.The Ancient Corporation of Cheadle” in the North Staffordshire Field Club Transactions for 1930. This actually turns out to be mostly relevant to the “Mock Mayor” tradition of Newcastle-under-Lyme. He also notes, in passing, the annual Hanley Venison Feast which he found could be traced to the 1780s.

1b.Medieval Glassworkers in North Staffordshire“, in the North Staffordshire Field Club Transactions for 1934.

2. Newcastle-under-Lyme in Tudor and early Stuart Times, Manchester University Press, 1938. Substantial, at 350+ pages. It is partly on Google Books, including TOCs. In an appendix are to be found useful castle-location maps that took account of the latest excavations (undertaken by himself and a group of his boys, 1934-1935).

3. The Restoration Government and the Corporation of Newcastle-under-Lyme, Manchester University Press, 1940. At 63 pages this third and final work for Manchester University Press was more of a booklet, perhaps due to wartime paper shortages at a guess. Google Books appears to have no preview, but on one of the versions it offers a simple TOC, and when you click the links for that you do get preview pages

THE INFLUENCE OF THE EARL OF ESSEX
THE CORPORATION ACT
COUNCILLORS DEPOSED
THE CHARTER GRANTED BY CHARLES II
THE LOCAL TRUSTEES
FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES
A ROYAL MANDATE
THE OLD ORDER AT WORK

It might be useful to get all of the above republished as a single volume, with a new introduction correcting any errors of fact and updating the reader.

He also produce a history of the town’s parish church, St. Giles, seemingly published (re-published?) in 1967.


His papers and photographs are in a special collection archive at Keele University, though a list is only available on request rather than being online in public. The page does however have a basic biography…

Thomas Pape (1872-1970) was a schoolmaster, holding posts at Newcastle-under-Lyme Middle School, the Orme Boys School and Wolstanton Grammar School. Pape devoted a great deal of his time to historical and archaeological research of Newcastle-under-Lyme and surrounding areas, authoring several books and numerous articles. He was elected a member of the North Staffordshire Field Club in 1917 and served as President in 1931.

Elsewhere I also found a picture of him…

Thomas Pape photographed in old age.

He taught History at Orme (called the ‘Middle School’ before 1914) and in his second book he states that he retired from teaching in 1933. This picture might have been made on that occasion, yet he looks older than 59 and the camera lens and picture-shape looks to be from a later era. My guess is he returned to teaching circa 1942 at age 70, due to the needs of the war, and this might date from that time? He lived to 98 years old, though, so it may even be later. Judging by his hands I’d say he could be in his late 80s here.

Evidently he also published articles in the local newspaper, and one observer remarks on… “Notes by medieval historian Thomas Pape, published in The Evening Sentinel newspaper in 1935″, re: a local pottery excavation.

He and his lads also excavated: The Roman Villa at Hales, Staffordshire; Chesterton Roman Fort; and from memory I’m fairly sure he was the one who did the excavations to find the bed of the Roman Road in the vicinity of Wolstanton (Chesterton fort to Stoke station).


Update: My thanks to David Pitt for a small correction. I had been led to believe, by Staffordshire Past Track, that Pape was serving as headmaster at Orme in 1927 when the Hales Roman Villa was excavated. I am informed that he was a History teacher throughout his career. This fact has been updated.

Amazon – from junk to junkie

Since when did Amazon UK become the nation’s pills-and-booze pusher? After the first few results it now show this, and many more like it…

I get the same results on a “clean” alternative Web browser with no addons or scripts, so it’s not my browser. Book searchers had become used to getting junk results, as pages filled with blank “notebooks” and the like. Now it seems Amazon has gone from ‘junk’ to ‘junkie’.

The Spoilt Kill

Yet another local novel of the Potteries, found. Where do they hide? The Spoilt Kill is a ‘police procedural’ crime mystery novel published in 1961 and set in what’s said to be a vividly evoked Potteries of the late 1950s. The obscure title refers to the name for the failed firing of a ceramics kiln.

The novel has recently been republished. By the British Library’s shovelware division, which has nice covers but doesn’t have a very high reputation for textual care. Yet at least the book is available again.

Formerly a mass-market crime mystery in the Penguin Crime paperbacks series. One can currently be had on eBay and the text there will be free of OCR errors.

There’s also an audiobook version.

The Folk-lore of North Staffordshire, version 1.6 (2021)

Here is a new edition of my free booklet The Folk-lore of North Staffordshire, an annotated bibliography. There are a number of newly discovered additions, some quite substantial, and a significant expansion of one item. All told, around seven extra pages are added and one new picture. Several of the new additions relate strongly to the wintry Sir Gawain landscape of the Moorlands, especially as I’ve now finally been able to see Sleigh’s book on Leek. As such the booklet now also forms a shelf-companion to my recent book on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight.

Download.

Please update any local copies you may be keeping. The previous revision was December 2020, when it was 24 pages. It’s now 32 pages and is again feasible to print as a booklet and slip between card covers.